Fair is fair

Milbank’s response to the London riots is surprisingly good.

5 Responses to “Fair is fair”

  1. Simon Says:

    Wow, a brilliant article!

    “For the time being, the rioters, however bad their actions – and actually because they have been so bad – must be seen as the victims of a wider national malaise as well as responsible actors who momentarily took some very wrong decisions.”

    That’s quite Lacanian, isn’t it? Even if the “criminality” is systemic, one is still responsible for one’s enjoyment in committing acts of “criminality” — knowing why one does it isn’t sufficient as a defence, because one still has to account for one’s fetishistic disavowal.

  2. Anthony Paul Smith Says:

    Yeah I was surprised. Happily so! His solutions are a bit hand wavy, but considering how awful his political interventions have been of late I’m willing to overlook them. For now.

  3. Brad Johnson Says:

    It’s rather sad, I think, when a conclusion such as “For this reason, a way must be found by the courts and the councillors to treat these young offenders at once firmly and yet sympathetically, for the sake of their better flourishing in the future” is not altogether common sense.

  4. adswithoutproducts Says:

    I don’t get the bit about parents shopping kids to the courts. Is he envisioning Elian Gonzalez type showdowns? I’m not sure “shopping” is the word when a squad of London Met types kick in your front door looking for your kid….

Comments are closed.


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 5,009 other followers